An Accusation.
Posted in disgust, plagiarism, silhouette 43 comments
What is a post? What is a poem? Ok, lets us go back. What are words? Still back, why do we write? I have heard and come to believe, that we write to express, and words are the bridge that lets us express. It helps us convey our emotions, feelings that build up inside, and that may be joy, pain, love, hatred, anything.
Bu then, why don’t we sing? Or why don’t we paint? Why don’t we dance? We do. We paint the words to dance, to the tune of our will. To express.
I was told, “Words are sacred, respect them.” And so I did. I always try to check for typos, though at times I overlook them. I try to write the full word and not use our modern “sms lingo” but at times I still do. I try not to be profane. For it would wash off their purity. But then, at times I cannot help, I become weak. I fail to check my language and curse the people who show dis-respect to what I believe is pure.
I write, when I feel the words building in me. I write when am touched inside. Touched by beauty, pain, or love. Today I write, for I am pained and there is dislike and anger. Why? For someone tainted the glass window, that showed me her picture. I know it still doesn’t make sense, what I say, but have patience my friends, for I will reveal my intentions.
People who write have the gift of expressing their thoughts through words. And people who read them, and leave a note commenting on them, have the gift to understand those words. My friends, we all are here on Blogger to express our thoughts and relate to others. To learn from each other. There are no rules for writing. You are free to write anything on your blogs. And the readers have the choice to read what they wish to. We do not follow a blog to get readership for ourselves, nor do we write for comments. We read to understand, to relate, and to communicate. And we write for the same.
Now, suppose a daily scenario, where you read a post and relate to it very well. Next thing, you leave a comment expressing the delight, your joy on being able to relate to it. The beauty, of the authorship, of those words which could touch your soul. Next thing, next time, you are eager to read his compositions, for who could weave such beauty once can surely do it again. You read, you comment. But then, what happens if those words lie? No, words can never lie. It’s the hand that wields the pen that has lied!! And its deceit he has lead you into, for making you believe that those words were his.
Why? Only that person can answer that question. What makes us so selfish to plagiarise someone else’s art and name them ours? Why can’t we appreciate the beauty of those words? Why do we have to darken our souls and steal?
Yes, this post is about it. Plagiarism. A dreaded word for an author. A sign of disrespect towards a gift. Blasphemy it is.
My dear friends, I wish put in front of your judgement, a situation. A fellow blogger has posted a write up under his name and collected all the accolades for it. Not anywhere has he mentioned the slightest of the hint that those words weren’t his.
The source from where it has been copied is not “Blogger” and the post is not a recent one. In fact, the person whose actual work it is, is a lady who had posted it way back on Nov 20th 2007. The link for which is this, and the link of the post, whose authenticity I question is this.
Sourav Pandey, I wish to hear from you. I wish you would drop a comment here on my blog. The person whose blog you have plagiarised is not my friend. The only relation we have is, we write. Yes, we WRITE. For me, writing is sacred gift. I respect it. You may claim that person to be you, for the author is incognito, but then, I ask, why would you write portraying yourself as a Lady? So I rule out the chance of it to be you.
Still if you do prove it your own, I promise you to write an apology similar to this accusation and post it here.
You have 372 followers and 1352 people liking your work. I feel disgusted thinking of the way you misguided them. For you lied to your friends, who admired your work. Conveniently, you have your comments moderated or I would have posted these very words of mine on your blog.
I challenge you to stand up.
Regards,
Eon Heath.
Bu then, why don’t we sing? Or why don’t we paint? Why don’t we dance? We do. We paint the words to dance, to the tune of our will. To express.
I was told, “Words are sacred, respect them.” And so I did. I always try to check for typos, though at times I overlook them. I try to write the full word and not use our modern “sms lingo” but at times I still do. I try not to be profane. For it would wash off their purity. But then, at times I cannot help, I become weak. I fail to check my language and curse the people who show dis-respect to what I believe is pure.
I write, when I feel the words building in me. I write when am touched inside. Touched by beauty, pain, or love. Today I write, for I am pained and there is dislike and anger. Why? For someone tainted the glass window, that showed me her picture. I know it still doesn’t make sense, what I say, but have patience my friends, for I will reveal my intentions.
People who write have the gift of expressing their thoughts through words. And people who read them, and leave a note commenting on them, have the gift to understand those words. My friends, we all are here on Blogger to express our thoughts and relate to others. To learn from each other. There are no rules for writing. You are free to write anything on your blogs. And the readers have the choice to read what they wish to. We do not follow a blog to get readership for ourselves, nor do we write for comments. We read to understand, to relate, and to communicate. And we write for the same.
Now, suppose a daily scenario, where you read a post and relate to it very well. Next thing, you leave a comment expressing the delight, your joy on being able to relate to it. The beauty, of the authorship, of those words which could touch your soul. Next thing, next time, you are eager to read his compositions, for who could weave such beauty once can surely do it again. You read, you comment. But then, what happens if those words lie? No, words can never lie. It’s the hand that wields the pen that has lied!! And its deceit he has lead you into, for making you believe that those words were his.
Why? Only that person can answer that question. What makes us so selfish to plagiarise someone else’s art and name them ours? Why can’t we appreciate the beauty of those words? Why do we have to darken our souls and steal?
Yes, this post is about it. Plagiarism. A dreaded word for an author. A sign of disrespect towards a gift. Blasphemy it is.
My dear friends, I wish put in front of your judgement, a situation. A fellow blogger has posted a write up under his name and collected all the accolades for it. Not anywhere has he mentioned the slightest of the hint that those words weren’t his.
The source from where it has been copied is not “Blogger” and the post is not a recent one. In fact, the person whose actual work it is, is a lady who had posted it way back on Nov 20th 2007. The link for which is this, and the link of the post, whose authenticity I question is this.
Sourav Pandey, I wish to hear from you. I wish you would drop a comment here on my blog. The person whose blog you have plagiarised is not my friend. The only relation we have is, we write. Yes, we WRITE. For me, writing is sacred gift. I respect it. You may claim that person to be you, for the author is incognito, but then, I ask, why would you write portraying yourself as a Lady? So I rule out the chance of it to be you.
Still if you do prove it your own, I promise you to write an apology similar to this accusation and post it here.
You have 372 followers and 1352 people liking your work. I feel disgusted thinking of the way you misguided them. For you lied to your friends, who admired your work. Conveniently, you have your comments moderated or I would have posted these very words of mine on your blog.
I challenge you to stand up.
Regards,
Eon Heath.
43 comments:
I was literally shocked.. How can someone claim anyone else's work? And that too someone as famous as sourav!
I may not write as good as him (what i thought was written by him) but atleast i have that dignity that whatever i post is 'mine'.. Too imperfect but atleast mine...
I second you eon here.. And yes, we need an answer!
Oh no, Eon, there seems to be a misunderstanding. The lady whose post seems to have been plagiarized, happens to be Sourav's friend, who had requested him to post that certain post of her's without crediting her for it. Reasons best left to them, Eon.
Hello Eon,
Since I don't know you much. I would rather NOT explain anything AT ALL! I have been reading and writing since I was 8! Yes. I respect words as much too. BUT, there are personal reasons for which you do certain things, and reading-writing is not beyond my personal life and space!
Meher (being one of my best blogger friend) answered that very politely, or otherwise I wouldn't have been bothered checking such a post. I know what I do and how I do and as she rightly pointed the reasons should be best left to me and the person involved. You (or ANYONE ELSE) may please go ahead, take actions, write posts, do candle marchs, hunger-strike, and stuff ..but that post remains on my blog with EVERY word intact!
Please do not expect a reply from me anymore. And my reply may be considered rude, but I am not liable to answer you, nor am I asking you to believe me.
Thank you!
@Deepika - You could have asked me directly, instead of such a kiddish comment! Anyway thanks!
have nothing to comment :). just cheer up Sourav and Eon.God bless u Both.
hmm i was shocked too...but guess meher's n sourav's reply explain a lot...well just chill now people...PLAGIARISM scares the hell out of me...n would disturb neone...ne writer...so it disturbd eon deepika n well me too...but well now tat things r settled...lets just get back to our normal ways...4get this...n be frnds again n respect words..:)cheer up people...
I think U were not in what u have done..as a blogger its our duty to act against plagiarism in the most stern ways!
I had read this post yest itself.and refuted to comment for the simple fact that sourav as an experienced blogger couldnt have done such a filthy job!
sarah
@Sourav
Well buddy,
i really wish you could come up with a better reply than banking on someones belief. i wudnt have accused you without conforming from the author first. She was surprised / annoyed that anyone could copy her post. So...that still leaves a piece unsolved. After that, i wish to put in another piece infront of you. Do you have similar stories for your other posts too?? for which i havent yet posted the links... most of them from the same forum...
Prove me wrong, i would be happy to post an apology... :)
Regards,
Eon Heath.
Blasphemy!
Mr. Sourav Pandey, stop loving yourself so much and start crediting even your best friends if you have to.
Also, I've been writing since I joined school, probably when I was 4 years old. I guess that makes me a better person than you.
Eon - awesome work here! Keep fighting!
Yay!! Sourav again unsuccessfully pulled out a scam.
Well, I think there has to be a clear answer from Saurav. He cannot, explain to all the posts that were linked.
Here is a list of posts that have been investigated and found out to be plagiarized
http://blog.indiblogger.in/2011/05/04/plagiarism-the-scourge-of-bloggers-everywhere/
@Kartikay
Ehhh, well, thanks?? i kinda find the whole situation weird to react upon...And honestly, it was Renie's and the Indiblogger team who finally did justice.
Hats off to them.
@Prateek
"Again"???
So Mr. Pandey here has been writing since the age of 8, and he still can't put two sentences together without copying from some source. Exceptional skills you got their dude. And stop being in love with yourself and don't show yourself off as a child prodigy of some kind.
@Meher: Stop being so disillusioned and get that blindfold out off your eyes.
@Hemal
Honestly, i dont expect him to answer at all...and that list put up by renie goes way longer...Renie has been considerate.. ;-)
@Eon hehe, yep Renie has to have his investigation complete. And with you and Lakshmi from Gingerchai helped him find out. Trust me, i am hurt as being someone who appreciated his work without knowing it was his work after all.
Top of it, he has won contests on IndiBlogger.in with his copied entries and have won more than two of the contests earning him Rs.50,000 in cash! Thats a big thing
@Hemal
Well, i do understand how it feels. Though i have not been following his blog,i have friends who did, and after conversing with them, i feel i owe them an apology for hurting them!!
Well Saurav has too many friends who prefer oblivion and want him bask in borrowed glory. Damn! am I jealous.....
@Purba
if the referal is for the ones who stood by his side here, well rest assured lady that they said those words for they believed in him, like any good friend would.
Like i said, he has mislead many and now is the time for him to stand up and talk...Not for himself, but for the people who believed in him. He owes it to them.
:)
@Eon i dont think you owe an apology for others but he certainly does..
@Snow Leopard
Well, i guess even back then he relied on the person sitting next to him for notes... ;-)
And as for your reference to Meher, buddy, uncalled for...she did exactly what any friend would do. And there are many who were dis illusioned by him...its not the fault of the people who follow his blog, its his.
Oh my!!!!! Blogging is no more of passion I think. SIGH!!!!!!
@Hemal
but still, its kinda sad to see your friends sad.. :)
@Kranjini
It still is. but unfortunately there doesnt exist a lake with no bad fish in it.. :)
Eerr just like a rotten apple in a basket full of juicy red apples....he he... ;)
@Kranjini
:D precisely....hehehe...
Eon, nice blog you have here, and just call me Ranjini :)
@Just Ranjini :P
thanks... :)
hehe..
Eon Heath... You dont owe any kind of apology, for you havent hurt anyone.
Get this in your head FOREVER!
I am saying it LAST TIME and I mean it!!!
@Poonam.doc
yes i get it. doctors are always right....my mom used to say... :P
Yes! Its better you get it. Dont you dare say it ever again, Dumbhead!
@Poonam.doc
aiy aiy doc... :P
We should recommend Sourav's work to fakingnews ;)
@Delhizen
aaahh!!! that would have hurt.... :P
I went back to the original post and posted my comment there for the post. Hope I could remove my comment from plagiarized post.
There is no point copy pasting for blogs. Hell, some Bollywood movies are better than that.
Chirag.
@Chirag Deshpande
:) true...
I too was totally shocked by all this. At first, i thought maybe the accused has some proper explanation but of course he does not and what he is saying lacks logic, especially when a lot of people whose work has been copied have no idea about it at all. I feel let down and cheated but then I guess this reaffirms the fact that we shouldn't trust people blindly. :(
@Mehak
i did get the email that was doing rounds...i thought of informing you about this post, but then i thought of letting you know once Renie was out with his research...
:) true what you said, and there are many more whole feel so....
Hi,
I own a blog http://umaspoembook.blogspot.com mainly writing poems .Recently when I googled my name ,I found out a particular site which used most of poetry without noticing me.http://www.bestbookreview.us/tag/exploring/ IT WAS A PAIN FOR ME.(This is only one link...he has nearly 10 of my poems in his site with every content and link just like that ).
I Comment him to remove the post..no reply.I found out him using WHOIS.com and mailed him...again yet no response...now seeing this thread..I am not the only one who is been targeted..Hope I get a good response from him
I can understand how the original authors feel about this when his/her works gets somewhere in some other place without even his/her notice...EON ,YOU STOOD UP !
You know what Eon Health,I used to admire his work,that poetic streak in those posts always amazed me.Looking at the way things have turned up as a reader I feel totally bamboozled!I know it is wrong to have a judgmental opinion unless you know someone personally but this is enough to decipher and learn for all of us.Blogging is not a business and our words are worth more than a million.It is healthier and lawful to speak and spend our own words.One CANNOT beg,borrow or steal them.If we do so it is a failure of our integrity as a writer.My many thanks to you for raising a voice...:)
@UmaAnandane
Well its sad to know that...but keep the fight going...
:)
@Raksha
Well i perfectly understand what you want to say. thought i myself never followed his works much, i do knw what it is the feeling when the deciet is revealed...
Words are sacred... :)
Oh my God! I am proud of you Eon. I indeed am.
:)
@Sneha
Well, the (in)famous episode...All i hope is something like this is not needed again.. :)
thanks a lot...
p.s.- How come you ended up here after so long??
Post a Comment